Are You Skilled in the Mystery of Contentment?

It has been a few years since I first read Jeremiah Burroughs’s classic The Rare Jewel of Christian Contentment, but now is the perfect time for a refresher, with Thanksgiving coming soon and my amnesia about God’s goodness at its usual ridiculous level. Philippians 4:11 served as the basis for his argument: “I have learned, in whatever situation I am, to be content.” Paul’s “situation” at the moment was a Roman prison.

He would have been in full agreement with Jeremiah Burroughs’s thesis statement:

The mystery of Christian contentment is the duty, glory, and excellence of a Christian.”1

A Secret to Be Learned

Christian contentment is a secret to be learned. When Paul wrote about contentment, he used a Greek word whose simplest translation is “self-sufficient.” He wanted to communicate his freedom from dependence on any created thing, and this is crucial because, while believers are not invited to share God’s incommunicable attribute of self-existence, there is a sense in which, at least spiritually, our contentment in Christ is a dim shadow of God’s self-existence (or “aseity”).

As usual, C.S. Lewis says it succinctly and distinctly:

He who has God and everything else has no more than he who has God alone.”

Contentment Defined

If contentment is a secret to be learned, we must define what Paul meant. Burroughs offers a very thorough description:

Christian contentment is the inward, quiet, gracious frame of spirit, freely submitting to and taking pleasure in God’s wise and fatherly disposal in every condition.”2

Contentment does NOT excuse complacency, nor does it mean putting up with injustice or passively accepting circumstances that should be changed and set right. Paul set the example by speaking out against injustice and held the magistrate’s officers’ feet to the fire when he and Silas were mistreated in Philippi.

What is the Secret?

Fortunately, Paul was not stingy with his secret, for he was quick to reveal his Source of contentment:

I know both how to make do with little, and I know how to make do with a lot. In any and all circumstances I have learned the secret of being content—whether well fed or hungry, whether in abundance or in need. I am able to do all things through him who strengthens me.” (Philippians 4:12-13)

Contentment comes from valuing Christ above all other possessions and relationships, above all other sources of strength and encouragement. It is a supernatural weapon in the trusting believer’s arsenal. Since God has commanded us to be content, he has also provided the means.

Contentment comes from valuing Christ above all other possessions and relationships, above all other sources of strength and encouragement. It is a supernatural weapon in the trusting believer’s arsenal.

The Miracle of Subtraction

When I read Burroughs’s work several years ago, this wisdom stuck like a burr:

Contentment comes, not so much by way of addition, as by way of subtraction.”3

Rather than adding to our possessions in hope that the pile will one day satisfy, biblical contentment carves down our desires until they equal what our loving heavenly Father chooses to provide. This, to me, seems to be the most difficult and yet most indispensable understanding of what it means to delight in the Lord without making an idol of his gifts.

Finding contentment in prosperity can be as challenging as finding contentment in suffering, and there is never a season of life in which we’re not tempted to complain—and then to make excuses for it.

Discontentment is an insidious evil, easy to overlook and hard to uproot. A mindset that views every single circumstance as a gift from God’s good hand is a frame of mind and heart that requires supernatural help and continual vigilance.  By grace, growth in Christian contentment will lead to a deeper fulfillment in the following life and a richer experience of gospel truth.

What advice can you offer for combating a spirit of entitlement and growing in contentment? Here are a few thoughts I’ve collected:

  • study the lives of biblical and historical figures who persevered with a spirit of contentment;
  • learn about the persecuted church;
  • become sacrificially involved in missions;
  • fast periodically from comforts that have become idols;
  • get involved in volunteer activities that are hidden and thankless;
  • give freely and extravagantly from your wealth;
  • pray fervently for  growth in contentment and setting the example for your family;
  • read deeply and widely from resources about seeking pleasure in God alone;
  • practice vigilance in your entertainment and social media exposure.

Finding contentment in prosperity can be as challenging as finding contentment in suffering, and there is never a season of life in which we’re not tempted to complain.

Holding You in the Light,


A Bible App Devotional Plan for the Season of Gratitude

For those of us in the United States, Thanksgiving falls in November. However, gratitude is not circumscribed by geographic boundaries. Nor do we need a calendar’s permission to leave room for gratitude, so whether you think of this series of devotionals as heart preparation for the coming season or simply want to retune your heart to the key of thanks, this is your invitation to pay attention to the steady stream of blessing that comes to us through God’s love. May we enter his gates with thanksgiving and his courts with praise, no matter what the season of the year.


Have You Read the Latest Newsletter?

On the third Wednesday of every month, I send a newsletter with biblical encouragement straight to my subscribers’ email inboxes. Frequently, I share free resources, and the newsletter is where all the news lands first.

CLICK HERE to find me on Substack, where my goal is to help you on the path of becoming a confident follower of God and a student of His Word.


Disclosure: I am an Amazon Associate, which means that whenever you purchase a book I’ve shared here through the link I provide, I’ll receive a very small commission. It doesn’t cost you more, and I only share books here that I can wholeheartedly recommend.


  1. Burroughs, The Rare Jewel of Christian Contentment, 8 ↩︎
  2. Burroughs, 22 ↩︎
  3. Burroughs, 25 ↩︎

Photo by Debby Hudson on Unsplash

12 thoughts on “Are You Skilled in the Mystery of Contentment?”

  1. Michele, revisiting The Rare Jewel of Christian Contentment before Thanksgiving is a great idea, and I smiled at your ‘amnesia about God’s goodness.’ Paul learning contentment in a Roman prison shows it’s a secret to be learned, not a personality trait. He Calls Me Daughter by Alejandra Cabrera Tash is a Christian book that helps women find their contentment in being God’s beloved daughters. I know the author personally, and I love helping share the good news about Jesus. This book speaks to the redemptive love of our heavenly Father!

    Like

    1. It’s so true that we can’t just dismiss Paul’s contentment as a “personality trait,” or even that he was a varsity-level Christian and, therefore, able to do something God the Holy Spirit can’t provide for us. Thanks for sharing the resource and your good thoughts!

      Like

  2. This was so helpful for me to read today, Michele. Especially this statement: “A mindset that views every single circumstance as a gift from God’s good hand is a frame of mind and heart that requires supernatural help and continual vigilance.” A couple of years ago, I would have said I was pretty content. In recent months, though, I’ve found myself ruminating on what I lack now rather than what I still have. Instead, I need to purposefully remember that God’s goodness and sovereignty covers every detail of my life and thank him for what he has allowed and provided.

    Like

    1. That’s certainly a spot-on corrrective move!
      I wonder if the transition into the empty nest (which always seems so abrupt, no matter how much we know it’s going to happen!) is requiring some very normal adjustments in what you expect about life in general and family specifically. I always wonder how women survive mothering without Christ!

      Like

  3. This quote from actor, Jim Carrey comes to mind when discontent begins to grumble: “I think everybody should get rich and famous and do everything they ever dreamed of so they can see that it’s not the answer.” I know that wealth, fame, accolades, etc. will never satisfy, but sometimes I need a reality-nudge. Only Jesus satisfies.

    Like

  4. Thank you for this post, Michele! What an encouragement and exhortation! I will be purchasing this book ASAP!

    Like

  5. Somehow this is one book I have never read. Looks like I need to put it on my reading list. Contentment seems like another of those things that we need to constantly remind ourselves of. We’re constantly bombarded by so many temptations to more “stuff” or more to do.

    Like

    1. This little book punches way above its weight with deft practical observations and deep biblical wisdom. I didn’t find it to be as hard to understand as most of the Puritans have been for me.

      Like

  6. It’s so interesting to think of contentment as something we can learn and choose because in today’s world many see it as something that just happens to the lucky people who have it all. Contentment is found in knowing the Giver of all the gifts we have and trusting that even if there were no gifts he would still be good and we would still be grateful that he is good. What a perfect lesson as we head towards Thanksgiving.

    Like

    1. Another quote I love from the book is that contentment is more about subtraction than addition.Rather than seeking to ADD more things to our life so we can find contentment, we can bear witness to the truth that no matter what is SUBTRACTED from our life, our contentment is in Christ.

      Like

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.